Whether it brings to mind a crispy, flavorful bread loaf or a fermenting blend of flour and water, sourdough holds a special place in many bakers’ kitchens. But where does the journey to sourdough bread commence, and how do you initiate it?

Start this adventure right in your home kitchen, commencing with creating your own sourdough starter.

A piece of advice: Sourdough baking is an art as much as it is a science. The method presented here may not precisely mirror what you’ve seen on another website, in a cookbook, or in your great-grandma’s journal. If you already have a successful process, feel free to stick with it or try this one for comparison.

The timeline provided assumes you can find a relatively warm spot (68°F to 70°F) to foster the growth of your starter – more details on that are explained below.

What is a Sourdough Starter?

Before going into the sourdough starter recipe, let’s explore what it is and the perks of crafting your own. At its core, a sourdough starter is a blend of flour and water, housing a stable mix of beneficial bacteria and wild yeasts.

Regularly refreshed, it’s the linchpin for leavening and flavoring new bread dough. Mastering its care is vital for home bakers adapting to variable kitchen conditions, ensuring bread with optimal flavor, texture, and longevity.

What are the Benefits of Making Your Own Sourdough Starter?

Making your own offers numerous advantages over store-bought sourdough:

  1. Distinctive flavor and texture: Homemade sourdough often offers a unique taste and texture, characterized by a distinct tanginess and a robust, chewy consistency.
  2. Total ingredient control: Baking your sourdough grants complete control over the ingredients, making it an ideal choice for those avoiding additives commonly found in commercial bread.
  3. Nutritional boost: The live fermentation process enhances nutrient availability and reduces phytic acid, potentially amplifying the health benefits of sourdough.
  4. Fulfilling endeavor: Baking bread with a sourdough starter provides a fulfilling and intellectually stimulating hobby.
  5. Economical option: Despite the time investment, homemade sourdough can be more cost-effective, particularly for frequent bakers.
  6. Unmatched freshness: Nothing surpasses the taste and aroma of freshly baked bread straight from your oven!

While homemade sourdough offers these benefits, it demands time and attention, especially in starter maintenance. Opting for store-bought sourdough remains a convenient choice when time is limited.

Making Your Sourdough Starter

On day one, mix one cup (113g) of whole rye or wheat flour with 1/2 cup (113g) of non-chlorinated cool water in a suitable container – glass, stainless steel, ceramics, or food-grade plastic all work. The preference for whole grain flour is intentional, bringing in more nutrients and sourdough-friendly microorganisms than standard flour. Stir thoroughly, leaving no dry flour, and cover the container loosely. Allow it to rest at a warm room temperature, around 70°F, for 24 hours.

An essential tip: Opt for non-chlorinated cool water for optimal results. Adjust the room temperature to expedite the starter’s growth; warmer spots near a heater work well. Investing in a temperature-controlled breadproofer or sourdough home is a game-changer for avid bakers.

During the initial 24 hours, you might observe minimal activity or slight signs of growth and bubbling. It’s worth noting that the starter may seem relatively inactive when viewed from the top.

However, a side view reveals the formation of bubbles beneath the surface. Regardless of the visible activity, discard half of the starter (approximately 1/2 cup) on the second day. If discarding feels excessive, consider maintaining a smaller starter.

Image: Shutterstock

Why is discarding half the starter necessary?

  1. Without discarding, the starter can accumulate excessively.
  2. Maintaining a consistent volume aids in balancing the pH.
  3. Keeping the volume down ensures more food for yeast during each feeding, promoting optimal growth.

To the remaining portion, add a bit less than one cup of unbleached all-purpose flour and 1/2 cup of cool water (if your surroundings are warm) or lukewarm water (if it’s cold).

Thoroughly mix the ingredients, cover the mixture, and allow it to rest at room temperature for the next 24 hours.

On day three, your starter should show activity. Begin two daily feedings, each involving 113g of starter, 113g of flour, and 113g of water. Repeat this process on days four, five, and onwards until the starter becomes active, doubling in size within 4 to 6 hours. Once it reaches this stage, give it a final feeding, discard excess, and store the remaining starter in the refrigerator for future use.

If your starter isn’t ready after a week, be patient and continue regular feedings. Successful starter development requires good flour, a consistent feeding schedule, and a warm environment. When your starter is robust, you can bake your favorite sourdough bread.

A Few Considerations Before You Begin the Process

Before starting the fermentation process, be aware that tap water with high chlorine or chloramine levels can hinder it. If your city uses chlorine, leaving tap water uncovered overnight helps dissipate it. However, if chloramine is used, this method won’t be effective. In such cases, opt for bottled or filtered water. Initially, opt for bottled or filtered water, then transition to tap water cautiously once the starter is reliably fermenting.

After mixing flour and water in the jar, cover it lightly with either porous cloth or a loosely placed lid, allowing at least five inches of headspace for potential expansion. To prevent overflow, place the jar in a bowl.

In the initial days, there might be a surge in fermentation followed by a decline, often misleading beginners into thinking it has “died.” Stay on schedule; the desired yeast and bacteria will stabilize the starter over time.

Temperature is crucial. Aim for a warm environment around 80°F to enhance activity. A home dough proofer or yogurt maker is ideal, but an off oven with the light on or a microwave with warm water also suffice.


What if I Miss Feeding My Sourdough Starter?

No need to fret – everything will be alright. Starters are surprisingly robust. If you miss a feeding, resume your regular routine, and your starter will adapt seamlessly. If you’ve missed a couple of feedings, continue doing it at room temperature every 12 hours until it doubles in size within the next four to eight hours.

What Should the Ideal Sourdough Aroma Be?

The sourdough starter should exude a distinctively sour yet “pure” aroma, devoid of any hints of spoilage or unusual chemical scents, such as acetone. While the robustness of the sourdough scent might initially give you pause, it should not be off-putting.

When is the Time to Replace the Neglected Sourdough Starter?

If your sourdough starter gets neglected, the liquid layer on top may change from clear to a darker hue. There’s no need to worry; just stir it back in and feed the starter. Yet, if you spot mold, notice an orange or pink tint, or detect a foul odor, it’s time to toss it out. These signs indicate harmful microorganisms have taken over, signaling the need to begin anew.